3. Working Papers
Permanent URI for this community
Browse
Browsing 3. Working Papers by Title
Now showing 1 - 20 of 236
Results Per Page
Sort Options
- ItemA Comparative Assessment of the Impacts of Malawi Farm Input Subsidy and Irrigation Policies on Child Nutrition Status(African Economic Research Consortium,, 2023-07) Chiwaula, Levison; Cassim, Lucius; Manja, LastonFarm input subsidy (FISP) and irrigation programmes are two of the top agricultural policy interventions that compete for resources in Malawi. Although pockets of information exist on the impacts of these policies, there is no study that compares the respective intervention impacts on child nutrition status to guide policymakers in the face of competing needs. Therefore, this study aims to fill this gap. Using data from the Fourth Integrated Household Survey (IHS4), an instrumental variables (IV) approach and quasi-experimental techniques of propensity score matching (PSM) were used to measure the impacts. The findings show that children from households that are beneficiaries of FISP have better nutrition statuses than children from non FISP or irrigation-practising households. However, the study fails to find a significant joint impact on child nutrition status, much less an individual impact, of irrigation policies, partly due to data limitations, which calls for a further, well-designed study to validate findings.
- ItemAccord Commercial Régional Approfondi Comme Moteur des Chaînes de Valeur Mondiales en Afrique : Le Cas de la Région de la Cedeao(African Economic Research Consortium, 2022-10) Balaki, Afi; Mamba, EssotanamCette étude examine les effets des accords commerciaux régionaux approfondis (ACR) sur les chaînes de valeur mondiales (CVM) pour 11 pays de la Communauté économique des États de l'Afrique de l'Ouest (CEDEAO) sur la période 1996-2018 en appliquant la technique de régression logit fractionnelle. Les chaînes de valeur mondiales sont calculées en tant que parts de la valeur ajoutée étrangère (VAE), de la valeur ajoutée nationale (VAD) et des exportations de VAD (VAD) dans les exportations brutes. Contrairement aux travaux précédents qui utilisent souvent la variable binaire, l'approfondissement de l'ACR est mesuré par un nouvel indicateur continu, le rapport entre le nombre cumulatif de protocoles et conventions ratifiés et le nombre cumulatif de protocoles et conventions signés. Deuxièmement, la présente étude analyse le contrôle de la corruption en tant que canal par lequel l'approfondissement de l'ACR influence les chaînes de valeur mondiales. Les résultats révèlent que l'approfondissement de l'ACR augmente significativement la FVA alors qu'il réduit la DVA, mais seulement au niveau de 10% et les résultats deviennent non significatifs avec l'inclusion de variables de contrôle. En outre, nos résultats indiquent l'existence d'une relation de complémentarité entre l'approfondissement de l'ACR et le contrôle de la corruption dans le modèle DVX. Les gouvernements de la CEDEAO devraient poursuivre la ratification des protocoles et des conventions et la lutte contre la corruption pour tirer parti de l'intégration profonde en termes de participation aux chaînes de valeur mondiales
- ItemAddressing Climate Change Cause and Effect on Land Cover and Land Use in Africa(African Economic Research Consortium, 2021-10-25) Adjaye, John Asafu-This study investigates the impact of climate change on land-use change and land cover (LCLUC)-induced greenhouse gas emissions in Africa. In particular, it tests the hypothesis that increasing agricultural productivity can be a land-based climate mitigation strategy to address the issue of LCLUC-induced emissions. The results confirm the well-known fact that climate change will have a devastating impact on Africa’s agricultural sector and therefore the welfare of the people. However, the results also clearly demonstrate that technology can be leveraged to improve agricultural productivity, which will not only enhance food production and improve food security but also mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. Specifically, we show that employing agricultural intensification strategies based on lifting total factor productivity can increase agricultural output with less land use, thereby saving millions of hectares of land from being brought into cultivation for staple crop production.
- ItemAddressing the Challenges of Sustainable Electrification in Africa through Comprehensive Impact Evaluations(African Economic Research Consortium, 2021-10-04) Muchapondwa, Edwin; Jeuland, Marc; Shimeles, AbebeAccess to electricity leads to overall economic growth through improved agricultural and firm productivity, public service delivery, and enhanced household investment in human capital, net income, and general quality of life. Yet more than 540 million people in Africa still lack electricity today, and many more suffer from unreliable power supply. The considerable untapped renewable energy potential, and the associated rapid reductions in cost, make sustainable and decentralized electricity service a promising option for the continent, for transforming these deficits into opportunities. However, knowledge on how to finance and implement new models of electrification remains limited, because the results from prior impact evaluations are inconclusive and do not cover all relevant interventions or dimensions. Following a review of policy and research issues, we propose that five essential principles should guide future research efforts in this domain: (i) use of mixed/multi methods that adequately cover the varied implications of electricity access, (ii) choice of econometric methods that provide more credible estimates of impacts, (iii) use and combinations of more informative treatment data, (iv) careful theorizing and consideration of the potential for heterogeneous treatment effects, and (v) accounting for effects from treatments of different magnitudes. We demonstrate the last three of these with an illustrative application of the World Bank Multi-Tier Framework data for Kenya. New insights emerge as research moves from a focus on average treatment effects to heterogeneous and multi-valued treatment effects. Notably, the impacts of electrification may depend on the extent to which households and other economic agents can make complementary investments to benefit from an electricity connection. Thus, electrification may need to be combined with complementary programmes, for example, those that make appliances more accessible and affordable. A greater focus on holistic impact evaluation approaches is needed to make economic research on sustainable electrification more informative and policy-relevant.
- ItemAfrican Firms in Global Value Chains: What Can We Learn from Firm-Level Data in Cameroon and Côte d'Ivoire?(African Economic Research Consortium, 2022-07) Coulibaly, Romaric; Moreno, Heddie; Akiko, Suwa-Eisenmann; Traore, NouhoumThis scoping paper exploits information from a unique data set constructed by merging firm census and custom data sets from Cameroon and Côte d'Ivoire to analyse the characteristics of firms that participate in global value chains (GVCs) in sub-Saharan Africa. These “GVC firms” are defined as firms that both export and import, with positive production and labour. The paper provides a detailed review of the state of firms' participation in GVCs in Africa and its consequences on trade, employment, and growth. The evidence in Cameroon and Côte d'Ivoire suggests that, in line with literature on firm heterogeneity and trade, firms engaged in GVCs are larger, more productive, and live longer than one-way-traders or domestic firms. Surprisingly, however, there are more GVC firms than pure exporters, a sign of the challenges faced by firms in those countries if they want to sell abroad. The probability of moving into a GVC is higher for exporters than for importers, showing that exporting is a stepping stone for firms to join a GVC.
- ItemAfrica’s Chronic Liquidity Challenges and the Role of SDR Allocations(African Economic Research Consortium, 2024-05-14) Shimeles, Abebe; Gallagher, KevinThe triple and overlapping global shocks faced by African countries have caused severe liquidity challenges in recent years. Many countries are currently experiencing low real GDP growth, higher inflation, exchange rate instability, balance of payments crisis, and a high risk of debt distress. The most critical is the increasing disruption that climate change risks pose to the macroeconomy, including worsening conditions of conflict and instability. In this regard, Africa is at a significant historic moment to resolve its development finance challenges to ensure a transition to a low-carbon economy while achieving the targets set in the Sustainable Development Goals. This paper outlines potential areas of reform in both the domestic and global arenas. It argues that the existing debt resolution mechanisms are obsolete, requiring novel and bold approaches, such as revising the role of Special Drawing Rights in relieving liquidity challenges in developing countries, mainly in Africa. In addition, the paper also notes that African governments need to seize opportunities created by the shocks to implement long-overdue structural and governance reforms to realize the continent’s enormous development potential.
- ItemAgricultural Marketing Policies and Household Dietary Diversity and Nutrition in Tanzania(African Economic Research Consortium, 2023-07) Martin, Julius Chegere; Kauky, Monica SebastianThe consumption of nutrient-rich foods is sensitive to changes in income and price shocks, especially for low-income consumers. This study employs Tanzania National Panel Survey data to explore the linkage between agricultural marketing, dietary diversity and nutrition status in Tanzania. Findings reveal that market orientation significantly affect dietary diversity for lower income groups, while for the whole sample, the effect is indirect through overall income. Household dietary diversity significantly correlates with a lower probability of child stunting, which becomes insignificant when overall income is controlled; and female education and overall income have significant effects on dietary diversity and child nutrition. The findings suggest a judicious use of money obtained from the sales of agricultural products.
- ItemAnalysis of the Effects of COVID-19 on the Trade, Transport and Health Sectors of Burundi(African Economic Research Consortium, 2021-10-08) Ndayitwayeko, Willy Marcel; Ntawiratsa, Rédempteur; Nkurunziza, DésiréThe unprecedented crisis caused by COVID-19 is affecting all aspects of society and the economies of many countries. This study aims at analysing the impact of this pandemic on the trade, transport and health sectors of Burundi. It is based on data collected using semi-structured questionnaires and interview guides applied on key informants. In addition, the analysis relied on monthly trade data from some ministries and public databases. The results reveal that there was a decline in trade when one compares values of exports and imports during the second quarter of 2020, which is the quarter when the country was in the pandemic compared to the same period in 2019, which is the period before the pandemic. Exports decreased from 99.1 billion BIF in the second quarter in 2019 to 30.8 billion BIF in the second quarter of 2020 due to COVID-19, translating to a decline of 68.92% for exports. Restrictions on movement of people and goods have also impacted on the imports of Burundi. Imports increased from 368.5 billion BIF in the second quarter in 2019 to 416.7 billion BIF, translating to a growth of 13.08%. However, imports are estimated at 433.00 billion BIF in the first quarter of 2020 from 436 billion BIF of last quarter of 2019, meaning a slight decrease of 0.6% from the first quarter to the second quarter. The results indicate that there is a very considerable drop in the value of goods that pass through these different modes of transport. For example, there was a 73.41% drop in value of goods passing through Melchior Ndadaye International Airport. The percentage drop registered by other transport companies are: Balloré Logistics (46.75%), Maritime Rail and Port Authority (54.89%), Volcano Transport Agency (83.97%) and Memento Transport Agency (84.84%). The results of the survey indicate that there was a very considerable drop in number of passengers using the different modes of transport. The percentage drop in passengers travelling through Melchior Ndadaye International Airport, Volcano transport and Memento transport were 99.99%, 78.74% and 77.55%, respectively. In the health sector, the results indicate that the weekly positive case rate has been consistently very low. This low rate could be explained by the decline of the voluntary COVID-19 test in the designated places by government. On average, the weekly testing rate since the beginning of the pandemic in Burundi is 2 per 10,000 inhabitants (per week); this is very low compared to the average threshold of at least 10 tests per week in the WHO African region. In addition, there has been a gradual decline in the screening rate. The overall screening rate estimated at 70 tests per 10,000 inhabitants remains low, with an average number of tests of about 290 per day since the beginning of the pandemic in Burundi. From the survey results, the study recommends provision of financial incentives and subsidies for transport, storage and cold chain costs for essential products; to provide non-contact food delivery mechanisms for high-risk or infected populations; prioritization of essential transport needs in supply chains; and periodic update priorities based on current risk assessments, for example at the height of an outbreak. On the transport and health sectors, transport of medical supplies and food is to be prioritized and given the "green light" (fewer stops, controls, tolls) when crossing administrative borders. Emergency transport for essential needs, fuel, food, medical supplies and equipment need to well planned, and planning for rationing of essential food and fuel. Information and awareness actions of the population on preventive measures should be reinforced, in particular on the effective implementation of barrier measures. There is need to build capacity in human resources, and ensure cross-border surveillance.
- ItemAssessing Export Supply Constraints: Methodology, Data, Measurement(AERC, 2007-06-07) Tyler Biggs
- ItemAssessing the Systemic Importance of Banks in Rwanda using Portfolio Similarity and Clustering Methods(African Economic Research Consortium, 2021-11-18) Ntirushwamaboko, Dominique; Mugenzi, Patrick; Nyalihama, ChristianThis paper assesses the similarity among Rwandan banks, especially looking at how the assets side and lending portfolios have been evolving, and their implications on systemic risks in the Rwandan banking system. The aim was to gauge a systemic risk that might originate from a cluster(s) of small banks, which is not well captured by traditional means of using the size or interconnectedness in network analysis. We used a variety of empirical approaches to tackle this aspect in the context of Rwanda, with data from 2016 to 2019. Our key findings suggest that the general measure of the portfolio similarity between individual banks is quite stable over time and driven predominantly by big banks. Conversely, we noted that some medium-sized banks have been consistently similar in terms of the loan portfolio and associated risks in the last four years, and therefore they can be exposed to common risks with impactful consequences, as the cluster is more sizeable than banks have taken individually
- ItemAn assessment of the Impact of China s Investments in Sudan(AERC, 2010-04-27) Kabbashi M. Suliman; Ahmed A. A. Badawi
- ItemAssurance Maladie et État de Santé au Kenya : Vers une Couverture Sanitaire Universelle(African Economic Research Consortium, 2022-07) Mugo, MercyLe troisième objectif de développement durable des Nations unies, qui vise à garantir une vie saine et à promouvoir le bien-être de tous à tout âge, souligne la priorité de la santé dans le programme de développement international. La réalisation de cet objectif au niveau national est toutefois entravée par les problèmes de financement des soins de santé. La plupart des pays d'Afrique subsaharienne, y compris le Kenya, sont confrontés à une charge de morbidité élevée et à des ressources financières insuffisantes pour financer la fourniture de services de santé. C'est pourquoi le financement des soins de santé par le biais de l'assurance maladie gagne en popularité dans les pays en développement dans leur quête d'une couverture sanitaire universelle. Cependant, il y a peu de preuves de l'impact de l'assurance maladie sur l'état de santé de la population au Kenya. Cette étude a cherché à comprendre et à analyser les liens de causalité entre le statut d'assurance maladie et les résultats de santé parmi les populations assurées et non assurées au Kenya. L'approche d'estimation adoptée est la méthode IV 2SLS et la méthode de la fonction de contrôle afin de tenir compte des biais d'endogénéité et d'hétérogénéité présents dans les estimateurs MCO. En outre, les techniques d'estimation probit et logit ont été adoptées pour analyser les déterminants de l'adhésion à l'assurance maladie. La principale conclusion est que l'assurance maladie réduit la mortalité, améliorant ainsi l'état de santé de la population kenyane. Et ce, malgré le faible taux d'adhésion à l'assurance, notamment à l'assurance maladie privée. L'étude recommande de promouvoir la couverture de l'assurance maladie par la restructuration des régimes fragmentés du NHIF en consolidant les différents régimes d'assurance afin de servir les différents groupes de population de manière plus efficace et plus équitable. Une autre recommandation est d'encourager l'adhésion volontaire privée et publique à l'assurance maladie en légiférant et en concevant des régimes de prestations complets et attrayants destinés aux acteurs du secteur informel ayant la capacité de payer. Le gouvernement devrait toutefois continuer à offrir des subventions sous forme d'assurance maladie aux populations marginalisées, vulnérables et pauvres.
- ItemAsymmetric Response of Poverty to Growth and Inequality in South Africa: Implications for Current and Future Shocks(African Economic Research Consortium, 2024-04-10) Ngepah, NicholasThis study investigates the effect of economic growth on poverty reduction, given inequality in South Africa. It focuses on whether the poor suffer more losses of welfare during economic recessions and depressions than they gain during expansions, and the factors that can assist the poor to stay afloat during times of economic shocks. Individuals in micro data set are matches with municipality-level data and in binary, truncated, panel, instrumental variables, and quantile regression techniques to estimate poverty and welfare effects of positive and negative economic growth rates. The study finds that, while economic growth reduces poverty, it is not enough to compensate for the poverty-raising effects of inequality. Moreover, economic decline raises poverty, but economic prosperity more than compensates by a higher magnitude. The study also reveals that, social grants and free health care and education policies have limited effects on poverty reduction during economic downturns. The findings call for policy measures that reduce inequality and promote economic growth to help cushion the poor during times of significant economic decline. Additionally, programmes that provide good education up to tertiary level and access to the labour market are crucial for sustaining poverty reduction efforts in South Africa.
- ItemAutonomisation des Femmes et Dépenses Sociales des Ménages dans les États Fragiles : Le Cas du Tchad(2022-03) KINDA, Aristide MABALI, Somlanare Romuald; MALLAYE, DouzounetLa fragilité de l'État au Tchad a été étroitement associée à l'insécurité due à un long cycle de conflits violents et à des sécheresses récurrentes, entraînant un faible développement social. Dans cet article, nous avons étudié l'impact de l'autonomisation des femmes sur les dépenses sociales des ménages en utilisant les données de l'enquête tchadienne sur la consommation des ménages et le secteur informel réalisée en 2011, et de l'appariement par score de propension comme modèle empirique. Les dépenses sociales utilisées comme variables de résultat sont l'éducation, la santé et l'alimentation. Nous constatons que les dépenses sociales sont plus élevées lorsqu'un ménage est dirigé par une femme que lorsqu'il est dirigé par un homme, à caractéristiques observées similaires. En particulier, les différences entre les ménages dirigés par une femme et ceux dirigés par un homme sont plus élevées pour les dépenses alimentaires après contrôle des caractéristiques observées (covariables). Les résultats montrent également qu'il existe un effet de composition dans les dépenses des ménages. Alors que les ménages dirigés par des femmes dépensent leurs revenus dans les secteurs sociaux (santé, alimentation et éducation), ceux dirigés par des hommes dépensent pour des biens dits de désir (alcool et loisirs). Ces résultats se maintiennent lorsque nous contrôlons à la fois la spécification du modèle et l'hypothèse de soutien commun. Nos résultats fournissent aux décideurs des outils de politique économique pour promouvoir le développement social en mettant l'accent sur l'autonomisation des femmes.
- ItemBridge Contracts in Africa: A Case Study of Orange Mali(African Economic Research Consortium, 2023) Greenacre, JonathanPeople incur transaction costs fitting their organizational arrangements into their surrounding property rights system. This paper analyzes organizational adaption to surroundings by examining which tool(s) from mechanism design people will use to solve moral hazard problems. Broadly, the weaker people’s surrounding property rights system, the more a principal will use tools from mechanism design, which provides greater autonomy to the agent. The paper finds support for this hypothesis by identifying ‘bridge contracts’, which Orange Mali uses to respond to weak property rights between urban and frontier communities in Mali. The paper proposes to use these findings to stimulate a ‘context specific’ approach to engineering economics. This involves developing mechanisms to encourage people to work towards social goals but also fit within specific communities. The paper applies this approach to random control trials.
- ItemCAPITAL FLIGHT AND INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORKS TO PROMOTE TRANSPARENCY(AERC, 2014-09) . Moshi, Humphrey P.BThe paper has three main objectives. First it identifies the kind of institutional frameworks at the global, regional and country level which have evolved to address the issues of illicit financial flows. Second, it analyzes the factors that have inhibited the efficiency and effectiveness of the frameworks. Third it proposes a way forward in terms of addressing the challenges with a view to achieve enhanced progress as far as the war against illicit financial flows is concerned. The main findings are: First, a variety of institutional frameworks has emerged at the three levels. However, they are interlinked and feed into each other, in the sense that those at the country level have been driven by those at the global and regional level. Given that most of these frameworks are not organic to Africa, the continent’s position has thus been more reactive than proactive. Second, the establishment of the institutional frameworks is an outcome of lobbying and advocacy organizations, spearheaded by non-governmental organizations and civil society organizations. This has been complemented by publications undertaken by a number of researchers in a variety of academic and non-academic institutions. All these efforts have underpinned the establishment of policy, legislative and enforcement frameworks at the country level. Third, the level of awareness, across a broad range of stakeholders, of the scope of the problem and its negative impact on African development, has been heightened. This notwithstanding, illicit financial flows continue to flourish unabated. A number of factors have contributed to this state of affairs. They include weak political will, lack of comprehensive legislation, weak enforcement capacities, continued existence of secrecy havens, corruption, and weak human and institutional capacities. Fourth, in order to adequately address the problem of illicit financial flows, solutions to the constraining factors must be sought, and the attendant measures effectively implemented. However, and most importantly, Africa needs to be proactive and own the process. The establishment of the High Level Panel at the Economic Commission for Africa (ECA) is a good starting point for spearheading efforts to combat illicit financial flows.
- ItemCAPITAL FLIGHT, SAFE HAVENS AND SECRECY JURISDICTIONS(AERC, 2014-09) Barry, FrankThe terms “safe haven” and “secrecy jurisdiction” are arguably more appropriate than “tax haven” or even “offshore financial center” in discussing capital flight. Florida, for example, is thought to be the main destination for capital flight from Latin America, though it is rarely—if ever—listed under either of the last two headings. Most capital flight is thought to reflect the transfer—typically to jurisdictions characterized by strong financial secrecy regulations—of the receipts of plunder, money laundering, and tax evasion. These same jurisdictions are occasionally used by governments to dodge reparations, evade the impact of sanctions, and/or covertly fund political interference in rival states. The paper considers how capital flight safe havens operate. It also reviews the arguments over financial secrecy laws and practices, and considers recent multilateral and unilateral attempts—by the OECD, the EU, the US and others—to counter secrecy abuses.
- ItemCapital Flight: Measurement and Drivers(AERC, 2014-09) Ndikumana, Léonce; . Boyce, James K; Ndiaye, Ameth SaloumThis paper describes the nature of capital flight, the methodologies used to measure it, and its drivers. The paper presents updated estimates of the magnitude of capital flight from 39 African countries for which adequate data are available for the period 1970-2010. It gives a global context of the problem of capital flight from Africa by providing comparative indicators on capital flight and related flows for other developing regions. The paper undertakes a detailed econometric analysis of the drivers of capital flight from African countries. It explores empirically the role of domestic and external factors in driving capital flight, including structural factors, the macroeconomic environment, governance, risk and returns to investment, capital account openness, and financial development. The first objective of the study is to contribute to the literature by providing the most comprehensive analysis of capital flight from Africa that takes into account economic as well as non-economic dimensions and recognizes the importance of both the domestic and global contexts. The second objective is to contribute to the policy debate on capital flight both in Africa and globally.
- ItemThe Challenge of Unemployment and Youth Unemployment amidst Fast Economic Growth in Ethiopia(2022) Geda, AlemayehuUsing a varies of approaches, this study examined the challenge of general and youth unemployment during the fast growth period of Ethiopia, 2000-2021. Apart from describing the recent profile of the labour market, I found a mismatch between the sectors that are the sources of fast growth and the sectors with significant potential for job creation. A simulation exercises carried to examine the employment effect of demand stimulus is not found to change this pattern although it could lead to an increase in output. The unemployment problem is accentuated by lack of structural transformation and low or declining productivity across sectors. The probability of being unemployed is also found to be relatively higher for females and youth, compared to males and adults, respectively. Government effort to address the youth unemployment problem through the establishment of technical and vocational training schools is not helping either. Based on the findings a number of policy implications are deriver. Among this, for instance, redirecting incentives and policy support to sectors with significant employment potential – the top three identified in the study being agriculture in general and animal husbandry in particular, agro industrial parks and labour-intensive manufacturing - could be important to address the challenge of unemployment.
- ItemChangement Structurel, Productivité et Création d'Emplois : Le Cas de la Tunisie(African Economic Research Consortium, 2023) Amara, Mohamed; Zidi, Faycel; Jeddi, HelaCette étude regroupe des analyses aux niveaux macro et micro afin d'identifier les principaux secteurs et entreprises qui présentent le plus grand potentiel pour stimuler l'emploi productif en Tunisie. L'analyse au niveau macro utilise des données agrégées au niveau sectoriel pour comprendre les principales caractéristiques des changements structurels, de l'emploi et de la croissance de la productivité. L'analyse au niveau micro ou au niveau de l'entreprise entre dans les détails du processus de réattribution en utilisant les micro données du registre des entreprises tunisiennes couvrant les deux dernières décennies. Les résultats empiriques montrent qu'une augmentation de 1% de la production industrielle génère deux fois plus d'emplois que le secteur des services pour la population en âge de travailler (15-64 ans) ; tandis qu'une augmentation de 1% de la production des services génère deux fois plus d'emplois que le secteur industriel pour les jeunes entre 15 et 25 ans. En outre, la croissance de la valeur ajoutée par habitant entre 2011 et 2018 était une "croissance sans emploi". Elle a été induite par une augmentation de la productivité et du taux d'activité, plutôt que par une augmentation du taux d'emploi. Le secteur manufacturier tunisien est entravé par un gaspillage et une mauvaise allocation des ressources entre les entreprises, les apports en capital étant détournés de leurs utilisations productives, trop de ressources allant à des entreprises moins productives. Les composantes intra et inter-entreprises ont un impact négatif sur la croissance de la productivité du travail et ralentissent les efforts visant à réduire le chômage. Cela démontre clairement la faible performance des entreprises en tant que créatrices d'emplois, tandis que les entrées et les sorties n'ont contribué que de manière négligeable à l'évolution de la productivité du travail entre 2000 et 2020.